(This article was originally published in October 2020. Reprinted here with updates.)

In 1967, David Butler spent a long winter helping his father plow the ground for 2500 apple trees on Mt. McAlpine, which overlooks the southern end of what is now the Village of Flat Rock. Little did that teenage boy know that he was actually planting the seeds for a very successful and rewarding life as the owner and operator of one of Henderson County’s most iconic apple orchards.

Today, David, his delightful wife/business partner, Lindsey, and their daughter Margaret spend each apple season overseeing Sky Top Orchard - a bustling agritourism business that attracts thousands of visitors to Flat Rock each summer and fall. What started in the 1960s as a commercial apple orchard is now a go-to destination for families and friends to pick apples, purchase apple cider, visit with Sky Top’s cute menagerie of animals, take old-fashioned hayrides, enjoy picnics, and - most importantly for many - eat the very best apple cider doughnuts in Henderson County.

Flat Rock was a very different place when Everette Butler purchased the original 80 acres on a mountaintop in 1966. “I grew up in South Florida, lived there the first 15 years of my life,” explains David. “But my mom and dad always loved the mountains, and my siblings and I actually spent time at summer camps here. This was just such a pretty piece of property. And I have to tell you it was very remote at the time!”

The Early Years

The trees David helped plant started producing fruit in the early 1970s. “Our first apples were harvested in 1971,” says David. “We were strictly a commercial operation then, so we sold to Gerber Baby Food and Ingles and Winn-Dixie, which was a big chain store at the time.” But the commercial apple business was not always lucrative, and success was not always a walk in the orchard/park for the Butlers. Much depended on uncertain variables such as weather, the relative abundance of crops from year to year, and fluctuating demand for apples.

David graduated from Hendersonville High School and left for college in the very early days of the business. He started at Florida State but eventually transferred to the University of South Carolina so that he could be closer to the orchard to help out on weekends and during the busier times of the year. While in Columbia, David managed to find “the apple of his eye” and ultimately returned to live full-time in Henderson County with his new bride, Lindsey. The young couple moved into the summer cabin on the orchard property and never looked back.

Lindsey admits now, however, she had no idea how her life with David would unfold. “When I met David, Sky Top was not open to the public. It was strictly commercial.” Sweeping her arm towards the hubbub of activity in the Sky Top pavilion and the orchards beyond, she adds, “I never dreamed that we would be doing all of this.”

David and Lindsey continued with commercial apple operations through the 1970s. Then in 1980, Lindsey proposed an idea that would dramatically alter the look of the Sky Top Orchard operation for the next 46 years. “She had the idea to offer an option of ‘you-pick’ because a lot of people wanted to come out to the farm to get some fresh fruit,” David explains. At the time, however, David wasn’t fully on board with the idea. “I reluctantly said ‘yes’.” And then, with a grin adds, “Over the years I’ve learned that it was a very, very good decision.”

Transition to Agritourism

As it turned out, Lindsey had instinctively tapped into a growing public interest in farms and agritourism. “Yeah, it was kind of my idea,” she recounts modestly. “People kept wandering up and asking, ‘Are you open to the public? Can we go pick apples? Can we see the orchard?’ So we kind of started very slowly. We sold apples in the yard and then through the years added things. I never dreamed we'd do it at this level.” Lindsey laughs as a nearby family with two young children picks up a basket and heads down to the orchard, “But it's a good thing!”

As the orchard - and the Butler family - grew through the 80s, David, Lindsey, and their three children remained committed to the enterprise and the lifestyle. “It was a challenge. But it was fun. Having apples and growing fruit has always kind of been my passion,” says David. “And when I look back on my life, I had to give up certain times on the weekends. My friends would all be going to do something, and we'd have an obligation at the orchard. But I wouldn’t trade our life for anything.”

Fully 46 years on from the initial decision to go to You-Pick, Sky Top has added a cornucopia (appleucopia?) of new activities, amenities, and menu items to its repertoire of things to do and see. The Bee-Train is wildly popular with the children and visitors to Sky Top will find two observation decks with spectacular views of the orchard and the surrounding mountains. They will also have an opportunity to fire an “apple cannon” that launches imperfect apples across the lake and into a pasture where goats and sheep will later clean up the fruity ordnance. A small but impressive menagerie of animals adds to the farm-like atmosphere of the orchard.

There are approximately 80 acres in production, and the Butlers now own a total of 120 acres. These days they live in a house on the property set high on a hillside with incredible sweeping views of the mountains of both North and South Carolina. The orchard has two full-time employees, a half-dozen part-time, and, as Lindsey describes them, a “multitude” of friends, children, and seasonal employees that keep Sky Top running smoothly for the season, which starts in mid to late summer and runs through Thanksgiving.

World Famous Sky Top Apple Cider Doughnuts

The Orchard Today

David credits a hard freeze that ruined the crop in 2007 as providing the “inspiration by necessity” for Sky Top’s World Famous in Henderson County apple cider doughnuts. David and Lindsey discussed what they could do with the damaged crop and David suggested baking apple cider doughnuts. In this author’s completely unbiased opinion, this was clearly the single best business decision David ever made - in a career full of many good decisions.

Ironically, what was arguably the most trying year in the lifetimes of most Americans, 2020 turned out to be a very good year for Sky Top Orchard. That fall was a good season for apples, and a visit to an outdoor venue like Sky Top was high on the limited list of activities for many during the pandemic. “We're very fortunate. Other local orchards didn't have as much luck as we did. So far we have a beautiful crop of fruit. And that's very rewarding,” says David.

A good crop is a blessing but not something the Butlers can count on from year to year. “You can count on one out of every five years to really be a tough year,” says David. “We have a big orchard with 30 varieties of apples. So we can survive one variety or another having a bad season. But even today, a hurricane could come in here with 60-mile-per-hour winds, and all our apples will be on the ground. So we always take it day by day.”

Visitors to Sky Top are genuinely grateful for the opportunity to spend time in the orchard. A fact which is immediately obvious by all the smiling and laughing families, the inter-generational feel of the crowd, and the almost palpable feeling of relaxation the crowd is experiencing as they are momentarily able to leave behind all the worries manifest during a pandemic. Lindsey loves to see the happy faces. “I love the orchard because of the joy that it brings. So many people say ‘Thank you for being open. It's the only normal thing I'm doing this fall.’ And so that's what makes it really special.”

Business partnerships can be fraught with peril, but David and Lindsey have grown up with the business - and each other - and have worked out an arrangement that allows them to keep both the orchard and their marriage intact. “We've learned to let each other have designated jobs and we try not to overlap the other's territory,” explains Lindsey. “You still bring home worries at night. But we each have our own place. You have to keep it a little bit separate.”

What's Next

After nearly five decades of operating Sky Top, David and Lindsey have also discovered that a successful business can be measured by much more than dollars and cents. In fact, during separate interviews, both of them became teary-eyed when asked what they enjoy most about operating the orchard. Their emotional responses make it clear that Sky Top is much more than a business for the Butlers. It is their home. It is the place they raised their three children. And it is the place that has allowed them to literally host generations of families that return to Sky Top year after year.

“We've done it for so many years,” says David. “We've taught a lot of school kids through the years, and now they come back and bring their families with them. The child that was 10 years old in that school group many years ago is now 32 and bringing his children back. We've been part of so many family memories, and so many people love this place as much as Lindsey and I do.”

The corners of David’s eyes well up with tears. “People come back and say, ‘I lost my mother or grandparent and one of their last requests was to come back up to the orchard for a visit.’ Wow. That's so touching that other people have that much attachment to this ground that has been such a huge part of my life and the life of my family.”

Lindsey has an equally emotional response when asked what makes Sky Top special. “The families that come here just…” Her voice catches as she looks out across the orchard and tries to compose herself. “I do get tears in my eyes when I think of all the stories we hear. People come up and tell us that they've been coming for 30 years and they get sentimental about being in this place. Maybe someone has suffered an illness, and they come up, and they're on their walker, and you can see how it's touched their lives. Or when people come up and are excited for us to meet their grandchildren. We’ve touched a lot of lives - which means so much to us.”

David with daughter Margaret, Sky Top General Manager. *(Josh Bell / Asheville Citizen Times)*

What does the future hold for the Butlers and Sky Top Orchard? Like the generations of visitors they’ve hosted, the Butlers have seen a lifetime of changes at Sky Top. The birth of their children. First days of school. Graduations. Weddings. And grandchildren. Not to mention employees that have become like family. All of which begs the question: How much longer will they do this? David laughs and says that he is not sure they will be allowed to stop. “I don't think we could close because a lot of people would be very upset with us.”

Fortunately, daughter Margaret has returned to Flat Rock and assumed the role of Sky Top General Manager, ensuring that one of the area’s most successful family businesses stays in the family. “I’ve loved this orchard ever since I was a little girl,” Margaret explains. “Even though I went off on my own for a while, the farm always called to me, begging me to come home.”

For the rest of the season, David, Lindsey, Margaret, and all their staff will be busy seven days a week from 9 am to 6 pm as thousands of visitors - often making a pilgrimage of sorts - arrive at the orchard to enjoy the apples, the activities, the views, and the chance to leave their everyday concerns in the parking lot.

When the season ends, David and Lindsey will sit down to discuss how much longer they will continue to operate Sky Top. And David has the same answer prepared every year. “I always tell Lindsey, ‘One more year. Let's do it for one more year.’”

For more information about Sky Top Orchard, visit skytoporchard.com .

The Apples of Their Eyes

The Trails of St. John